Nine Men's Morris strategy: how to win
Nine Men's Morris looks like a race to make mills, but strong players spend the placing phase on something else: getting their pieces onto points where they can still move later, and setting up the threats that pay off once the board is full.
This guide goes from the first rules of thumb to the ideas that decide games: double threats, the double mill and the blockade. Every position comes from a real game, and you can play the key moves yourself.
What to check before every move
Most lost games are lost to a mill that was on the board, one move away, for a turn or two. Going through the same short list before every move prevents that.
- Can I close a mill now? Usually do it, and choose the piece you take with care.
- Can my opponent close a mill next turn? Block it, unless you can make a threat of your own that they must answer first.
- Will my pieces still be able to move? A piece hemmed in on a corner is nearly lost once the moving phase starts.
- Only then look for a move that builds your own threats.
Each point lies on exactly two lines. Before you place or move a piece, look along both of them, for your own threats and for your opponent's.
Where to place your pieces
In the placing phase it is tempting to chase mills. Experienced players think about the moving phase instead: once all 18 pieces are down, only six points are empty, and a piece without an empty neighbour cannot move.
Points differ a lot in how many neighbours they have, and so in how easily a piece there can move later and how many lines it helps to block.
So the four crossroads of the middle square are the best points on the board, and the twelve corners the weakest. That does not mean never using a corner, but a corner piece is easily hemmed in, so place one there only when it does a job, such as blocking a threat. In this game White opened on three of the four crossroads.
A mill in the placing phase takes one piece, but your opponent still has pieces to place and can often put one right back. If the mill costs you good points and leaves your pieces on corners, you may end the placing phase unable to move.
Blocking a mill
When your opponent has two pieces on a line and the third point is empty, they close a mill on their next turn. While placing, any empty point can be filled, so the threat must be blocked at once, unless you can make a threat of your own that they have to answer first.
In this game Black has just placed a piece that makes a threat. Where must White play?
Make your move on the board.
Show the answer
Place on b4. Black's b6 and b2 need only b4 to close the line b6, b4, b2. White has no threat of its own to make instead, so blocking is the only move that stops Black's mill.
Two threats at once
One threat can be blocked. Two cannot, if both can be closed on the next turn: the opponent fills one point and you close a mill on the other. Most pieces won in the placing phase come from such a double threat.
The trick is a point that lies on two of your lines at once. In this game White has two pieces on the inner and middle squares that can be joined by one more.
Make your move on the board.
Show the answer
Place on c4. It makes two threats at once: a4, b4, c4 across the left side, and c5, c4, c3 up the inner square. Black has no threat of its own to answer with, so whatever Black does, White closes a mill next turn.
Which piece to take
Closing a mill is only half the turn. The piece you take decides what your opponent can do next, so choose it as carefully as the move itself.
The best piece to take is usually one your opponent needs for a threat, above all a piece that belongs to two threats at once. In this game Black can close a mill, and White has two threats on the board.
Make your move on the board.
Show the answer
Place on d2, closing b2, d2, f2, and take a4. Any other piece leaves White a mill on the next turn. In the game White answered with c4, a new double threat on a4 and c5, and won a piece back: while pieces are still being placed, a gap you open can be filled again.
The double mill
The strongest formation in the game is the double mill: five pieces arranged so that one of them closes a mill each time it moves out of the other. It swings back and forth and takes a piece on every turn. In German it is called a Zwickmühle, and the name has passed into everyday speech for a situation with no way out.
A double mill works only if the opponent cannot step into the points the swinging piece leaves. In this game Black has just moved g4 to f4. Black's piece on d6 now stands between two lines: f6, f4, f2 on one side and d7, d6, d5 on the other, and no white piece can reach d6 or f6. Watch what happens.
White steps g1 to g4. Black swings d6 over to f6: f6, f4 and f2 are a mill, and Black takes d1.
White goes back to g1. Black's piece returns to d6, closing d7, d6, d5 again, and takes e4.
No white piece can reach d6 or f6. Black swings to f6 once more and takes d2.
White fills d2 again from b2, and Black takes that piece as well on the way back to d6.
Black's fifth mill in five turns takes c3, and White is down to three pieces.
Against a double mill there is no defence once it runs, so stop it before it forms. Keep a piece next to the points your opponent's mills use, so you can step into a gap when they open one, and take a piece of a half-built double mill when you get the chance.
Blockades: winning without mills
You do not need to take many pieces to win. In the moving phase a player who cannot move loses, so a strong side can also win by hemming the other in, often while still behind on pieces or level with them.
In this game the placing phase has just ended, and only one of White's eight pieces, on g4, can move at all. Black has a mill on d7, d6, d5, and no white piece stands next to d6.
White's only move is g4 to g7. Black opens its mill by stepping d6 to f6; White has no piece next to d6, so the gap cannot be filled.
White must go back to g4, its only move. Black closes the mill again with f6 to d6 and takes g4, the last white piece that could move. White still has seven pieces, but no legal move, and loses.
Seven pieces that cannot move are worth nothing. In the placing phase, check where each piece will be able to go once the board is full, and keep at least two of your pieces next to empty points.
Three pieces and flying
With three pieces left, a player flies, and the game changes. A single threat is no longer enough against them, because a flying piece can fill any gap at once. The side with more pieces usually wins by making two threats at the same time; the flying side can block only one.
For the flying side, every turn is a chance to strike anywhere: two flying pieces on a line close a mill as soon as the third point is free. In this game Black has three pieces against White's eight.
Make your move on the board.
Show the answer
Fly d7 to f4 and take c4. White's e5, e4, e3 and d3, d2, d1 are mills, so only a4 and c4 can be taken, and only c4 can reach a mill next turn, by stepping to c3.
When both players are down to three pieces, both fly, and whoever makes the first double threat usually wins. On this site such a game is a draw if neither side wins within ten moves each.
What perfect play looks like
In 1993 the computer scientist Ralph Gasser solved Nine Men's Morris: with perfect play from both sides, the game is a draw. The computer worked out every position of the moving phase and then searched the placing phase from the empty board.
For players this is good news. Nobody plays perfectly, so games are decided by mistakes, and the ideas on this page are how you avoid making them and punish them when your opponent does.
Practise
Ideas stick when you use them. Play the computer and go through the checklist before every move: your mills, your opponent's threats, and where your pieces will move once the board is full. Start on a level where you win about half your games and move up from there, or invite a friend to a game online.
Learn, Play, and Have Fun!
Ready to play Nine Men's Morris online? Start a match against the computer now. No signup, no friction.
